An AI answer can name a nonexistent case, misquote a real judgment or attach a real citation to an unsupported proposition. Verify both the decision's identity and what it actually says before relying on it.
How do I find the judgment behind an AI citation?
Write down the case title, court, date, case number and citation supplied by the tool. Use the court's official judgment service to locate the decision. The Supreme Court case-number search provides a starting point for Supreme Court decisions; use the relevant court's service for other judgments.
Check the downloaded text against the identity details. If you cannot locate the original, label the citation unverified and keep it out of a filing until resolved. A failed search alone does not prove that a case is fabricated: the title, citation or indexing may need further checking.
How do I know whether a real judgment supports my argument?
Write the exact proposition you want the case to support. Find the cited paragraph or page, then read the surrounding reasoning and the final order. Distinguish a party's submissions, quoted material and background facts from what the court decided.
Consider the court, bench, procedural posture and material facts. A decision about the same statute can still answer a different question.
A fictional example: the case exists, but the proposition fails
Suppose a generated note says, “The court held that delay always requires bail.” You find the judgment, but the relevant passage only records counsel's submission and the court's reasoning does not adopt that proposition. The case is real; the generated claim remains unsupported. Correct or remove that claim and continue researching the actual issue. This is an illustrative checking exercise, not a statement of bail law or a report of a product test.
What if the quote is close but not exact?
Compare quoted words directly with the judgment. Label a paraphrase as a paraphrase. Do not present a generated explanation as the court's wording or turn a qualified observation into an absolute rule.
What else should I check before relying on the authority?
Check later treatment and whether statutory changes affect the proposition. An authentic quotation may still be inapplicable to the current issue. Ask the responsible advocate to resolve conflicting authorities and assess the decision's weight for the intended forum.
A linked source is useful because it allows inspection; the link itself does not complete that inspection.
How do I keep a verification record?
Use one row per authority. Keep unresolved questions visible until the responsible advocate settles them.
| Field | What to record |
|---|---|
| Proposition | The precise point the draft attributes to the court |
| Case identity | Title, court, date, case number and citation |
| Original source | Judgment URL or saved source file |
| Pinpoint passage | Paragraph or page and the supporting wording |
| Context and relevance | What the court decided and why it applies to the issue |
| Later checks | Subsequent treatment and relevant statutory changes checked |
| Review status | Reviewer, review date and unresolved questions |
Can I skip verification when using a specialist legal AI tool?
Apply the same checks to any AI-generated research, including JuniorLawyer. Specialization, retrieval and citation-shaped links do not establish that a particular proposition is correct. Keep source text separate from generated analysis and exclude authorities that remain unverified.
When comparing tools, use the drafting-tool trial scorecard to check source access and review effort alongside the generated text.