Criminal Law

Section 63 BSA Certificate: How to Prove Electronic Evidence in Indian Courts

JT

Juniorlawyer Team

Published: · 8 min read

CCriminal Law

QUICK ANSWER

What is a Section 63 BSA certificate?

A Section 63 BSA certificate supports admission of an electronic-record copy when the BSA applies and its conditions are met. The BSA commenced on 1 July 2024, but Section 170(2) preserves the Indian Evidence Act, including Section 65B, for matters pending immediately before commencement. The BSA Schedule has two parts:

  • Part A: filled and signed by the party producing the record
  • Part B: filled and signed by an expert
  • Identifies the record, the device and how the copy was made
  • Records the copy's hash value and includes the hash report
  • Filed with the record each time it is submitted

A Section 63 certificate under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) supports proof of a copy of an electronic record without producing the original device, subject to the section's conditions. Where the BSA applies, filing a WhatsApp printout, CCTV copy, call detail record or email without the required certificate can lead to an admissibility objection. The BSA commenced on 1 July 2024 and prescribes a certificate form with two parts.

Check which evidence law applies first. Section 170(2) preserves the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 for any application, trial, inquiry, investigation, proceeding or appeal pending immediately before the BSA commenced. Those saved matters continue under the old Act, including Section 65B where applicable. The date on which you file the electronic record alone does not decide which certificate regime applies.

This guide explains when you need the certificate, what goes into each part, who signs it, and the mistakes that get electronic evidence rejected.

How Sections 61, 62 and 63 BSA work together

Three provisions of the BSA deal with electronic records:

  • Section 61 says an electronic or digital record cannot be refused admission only because it is electronic. It is subject to Section 63.
  • Section 62 says the contents of an electronic record may be proved in accordance with Section 63.
  • Section 63 treats a printout or copy of an electronic record (stored on optical or magnetic media or semiconductor memory, and produced by a computer or communication device) as a document. That copy is admissible without the original if the conditions in the section are met and the certificate under Section 63(4) is filed.

Compared with Section 65B, Section 63 expressly covers communication devices such as mobile phones and semiconductor memory such as pen drives and memory cards. It also requires the certificate in the form set out in the Schedule to the Act, signed by the person in charge of the device and an expert.

When you need the certificate, and when you don't

You need a Section 63 certificate when you rely on a copy: a printout, screenshot, CD, pen drive or other copy of the electronic record.

You may not need one when you produce the original device itself, for example when the owner of the phone brings it to court and proves the messages from the witness box. The original is then primary evidence. In practice most parties file copies, because devices are in daily use, held by someone else, or seized by the police.

Section 63(4) requires the certificate to be submitted along with the electronic record at each instance where it is submitted for admission. A certificate filed with the plaint or complaint does not automatically cover a fresh copy produced later.

What the Schedule certificate contains

The form in the Schedule to the BSA has two parts.

PartFilled byWhat it covers
Part AThe party producing the record (or the person in lawful control of the device)Who is giving the certificate; the device (make, model, serial or IMEI number); whether the device was in regular use and working properly; how the record was produced or copied; the hash value of the copy and the algorithm used
Part BAn expertThe expert's details; the device or digital record source (type, make, model, serial or IMEI number); the hash value of the record and the algorithm used, with the hash report enclosed

The form does not ask the expert to state that the two hash values match. Compare the Part A and Part B values yourself before filing: a mismatch will be the first thing the other side checks.

Use the form exactly as it appears in the Schedule rather than an old Section 65B template. Fill in every field; an unexplained blank is an easy point for the other side.

The Schedule also requires the hash report to be enclosed with the certificate. Recording the hash value and algorithm in the form does not replace this attachment.

Who counts as the "person in charge"

Section 63(4) refers to the person in charge of the computer or communication device, or the person managing the relevant activities, whichever fits. For a personal phone that is usually its owner. For CCTV in a shop or housing society it is the person who manages the system. For bank or telecom records it is an officer who manages those records, often a designated nodal officer.

Who counts as the "expert"

The BSA does not define the qualifications of the expert who signs Part B. Practice is still settling across courts. An Examiner of Electronic Evidence notified under Section 79A of the Information Technology Act, 2000, or a government forensic laboratory, is the safest choice where a record is likely to be disputed. Check what your court has accepted before relying on a private technician.

Common types of electronic evidence

RecordTypical copy filedWho usually signs Part A
WhatsApp or other chat messagesPrintout or exported chat with mediaThe phone's owner or user
CCTV footageClip on a pen drive or CDThe person who manages the CCTV system
Call detail records (CDR)Printout from the telecom providerThe provider's nodal officer
EmailsPrintout with full headers, or exported fileThe account holder, or the organisation's system administrator
Social media postsScreenshots with URL, date and timeThe person who captured them
Audio or video recordingsCopy on a pen drive or CD, with a transcriptThe person who recorded them or controls the device

Screenshots are the weakest form. Where you can, export the chat or file from the device and record its hash value at the time you copy it.

What the Supreme Court said under Section 65B

The leading judgments were decided under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act. Section 63 BSA keeps the same structure, so courts look to them, but check how your High Court has applied them to the BSA.

  • Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473: a copy of an electronic record is admissible only with the certificate; oral evidence cannot take its place.
  • Shafhi Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2018) 2 SCC 801: relaxed the requirement where the party producing the record did not control the device.
  • Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 7 SCC 1: overruled Shafhi Mohammad on that point and held the certificate to be a condition precedent for admitting a copy. It is not needed when the original device is produced. A party who cannot obtain the certificate from the person in control of the device can ask the court to order its production, and the court may allow a certificate to be filed at a later stage if that causes no prejudice to the other side.

Do not plan around a late certificate. File it with the record whenever you can.

Step by step: preparing electronic evidence for filing

  1. Preserve the original. Keep the phone, DVR or account unaltered. Note who holds it from now on.
  2. Make the copy carefully. Export the record rather than photographing a screen. Note the date, time and method of copying.
  3. Calculate the hash value of the copy (SHA-256 is widely used), record it with the algorithm, and enclose the hash report with the certificate as required by the Schedule.
  4. Fill Part A with the device details and the copying process, and have the person in charge sign it.
  5. Get Part B from an expert who records the device details and the hash value of the record, and check that it matches the value in Part A.
  6. Index the exhibit. Give each record an exhibit number, list it in the index of documents, and attach the certificate to it.
  7. Submit the certificate with the electronic record at each instance it is submitted for admission. Section 63(4) does not expressly require a newly executed certificate every time an unchanged record is submitted. Check that the certificate covers the particular record and follow any directions of the court.

Mistakes that get electronic evidence rejected

  • Filing printouts or screenshots with no certificate at all.
  • Using an old Section 65B template instead of the Schedule form.
  • A certificate signed only by the party, with no Part B from an expert.
  • The advocate signing the certificate instead of the person in charge of the device.
  • Device details (model, serial or IMEI number) that do not match the device.
  • No hash value, or a hash value that does not match the copy produced in court.
  • Omitting the hash report required by the Schedule.
  • Relying on a certificate that identifies a different copy. Under Section 63(4)(a) the certificate must identify the electronic record produced, so a new copy or export needs a certificate that describes it.

Organising the evidence file

Electronic evidence usually arrives as a mix of exports, screenshots and scanned printouts. In Juniorlawyer you can keep these in the matter's documents, run OCR on scanned printouts so they are searchable, and use the Chronology Builder to place each message or clip on a dated timeline linked back to its source page. That timeline is also useful when you prepare to cross-examine a witness on the electronic record.

Software can help you organise the record and prepare a first draft of the Part A narrative from facts you supply. It cannot vouch for a device. The person in charge and the expert must check every detail and sign only what they can confirm.

_This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Check the current text of the BSA and the practice of your court before filing._

Choose your next step

What would you like to check before applying this legal guide?

Which provision and version of the law apply to this matter?

  1. Locate the provision in an official source.
  2. Check commencement dates, amendments and any relevant exceptions.
  3. Ask the reviewing advocate how the provision applies to the facts.
Find legislation on India Code

Frequently Asked Questions

Share this article

Try JuniorLawyer on your next matter

Draft, translate, run OCR and research in one workspace. Free plan, no credit card required.

Organise your evidence file in Juniorlawyer →

Prefer a walkthrough? Book a demo