Legal Drafting

Order 7 Rule 11 CPC: Rejection of Plaint, Grounds and Application Format

JT

Juniorlawyer Team

Published: · 12 min read

LLegal Drafting

QUICK ANSWER

What is Order 7 Rule 11 CPC?

Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 tells the court to reject a plaint at the threshold, without a trial, on six grounds. The court reads only the plaint and the documents filed with it; the defendant's written statement is irrelevant at this stage.

  • (a) The plaint discloses no cause of action
  • (b) The relief is undervalued and the valuation is not corrected in time
  • (c) The plaint is insufficiently stamped and the stamp is not supplied in time
  • (d) The suit appears from the plaint to be barred by any law
  • (e) The plaint is not filed in duplicate; (f) Rule 9 is not complied with

Jump to the format

Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) lets a suit be thrown out at the start, before issues are framed or evidence is led. If the plaint, read on its own, shows no cause of action or a suit barred by law, the court must reject it. For a defendant, a well-drafted Order 7 Rule 11 application can end a suit in months instead of years. For a plaintiff, knowing the grounds is the best way to draft a plaint that survives one.

This guide covers the six grounds, what the court may and may not look at, how limitation and res judicata are treated, the commercial-suit mediation bar, an application format and a reply format, and the remedies after the order.

The six grounds in Order VII Rule 11

The rule says the plaint shall be rejected in the following cases:

ClauseGroundWhat to check
(a)The plaint does not disclose a cause of actionDo the averments, taken as true, give the plaintiff a right to the relief claimed?
(b)The relief is undervalued, and the plaintiff does not correct the valuation within the time the court fixesThe court must first direct correction; rejection follows only on default
(c)The relief is properly valued but the plaint is on insufficiently stamped paper, and the plaintiff does not supply the stamp within the time the court fixesSame: a direction first, rejection only on default
(d)The suit appears from the statement in the plaint to be barred by any lawLimitation, an express or implied statutory bar, a missing mandatory notice or pre-suit step
(e)The plaint is not filed in duplicateOrder IV Rule 1 requires a duplicate
(f)The plaintiff does not comply with Rule 9Copies of the plaint for service on the defendants and the required fees

Clauses (e) and (f) were added by the CPC amendments that took effect in 2002.

The proviso limits extensions under clauses (b) and (c). The court may extend the time it fixed for correcting the valuation or supplying stamp paper only if, for reasons recorded, it is satisfied that the plaintiff was prevented by a cause of an exceptional nature and that refusing more time would cause grave injustice.

Rejection (Rule 11) versus return (Rule 10)

These two are often confused in applications. Use the right one.

Order VII Rule 10: return of plaintOrder VII Rule 11: rejection of plaint
GroundThe court lacks jurisdiction (territorial, pecuniary or subject matter) to try the suitOne of the six grounds above
ResultThe plaint goes back to be presented in the proper courtThe suit ends in this court
Is the order a decree?No. An order returning a plaint is appealable under Order XLIII Rule 1(a)Yes. Section 2(2) CPC treats rejection of a plaint as a decree
Fresh suitPresented in the proper courtAllowed by Rule 13 on the same cause of action, unless another law bars it

If the real objection is that another court should hear the suit, ask for return under Rule 10, not rejection.

What the court may look at

The Supreme Court has settled how an Order 7 Rule 11 application is decided:

  • Only the plaint and the documents filed with it. In Saleem Bhai v. State of Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557, the Court held that for clauses (a) and (d) the averments in the plaint are what matter, and the pleas in the written statement are wholly irrelevant at that stage. It set aside a direction to the defendant to file a written statement before the application was decided.
  • The averments are taken as true. The court does not ask whether the plaintiff will win, only whether the plaint, read as a whole with its documents, discloses a right to relief.
  • Read the plaint meaningfully, not formally. In T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal, (1977) 4 SCC 467, the Court said that if clever drafting creates only an illusion of a cause of action, the suit should be nipped in the bud.
  • The leading summary is Dahiben. Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali, (2020) 7 SCC 366, collects the principles: the remedy is an independent and special one, the court may exercise it at any stage of the suit, documents filed with the plaint are considered, and if the plaint does not disclose a right to sue the court is bound to reject it.

Do not attach your own documents to the application and ask the court to rely on them. Anything that is not in the plaint or filed with it belongs in the written statement and the trial.

Ground (d): when a suit is "barred by law"

Clause (d) is the most argued ground. The bar must appear from the plaint itself.

Limitation

A suit filed after limitation must be dismissed under Section 3 of the Limitation Act, 1963, and Section 5 cannot save a suit. Whether the plaint can be rejected at the threshold depends on how clear the bar is:

  • In P. Kumarakurubaran v. P. Narayanan, 2025 INSC 598, the Supreme Court held that where the date on which the cause of action arose is disputed and needs evidence, limitation becomes a mixed question of law and fact and cannot be decided under Order 7 Rule 11.
  • In N. Asha Devi v. R. Aravind Kumar, 2026 INSC 908, the Court said courts need not hesitate to reject a plaint where the limitation bar is evident from the plaint itself.

The practical test: point to the dates pleaded in the plaint that show the suit is out of time. If you need a document the plaintiff did not file, or a fact the plaintiff denies, the objection belongs in the written statement and will usually be decided at trial with the other issues. It can be tried first under Order XIV Rule 2(2) only if it can be decided as a question of law without resolving disputed facts (see the next section).

Watch for clever drafting on limitation: a plaint that pleads a fresh "cause of action" on the date of a recent legal notice or a refusal, when the real grievance is years older. Courts look through this when the older dates are in the plaint or its documents.

Res judicata

In Srihari Hanumandas Totala v. Hemant Vithal Kamat, (2021) 9 SCC 99, the Supreme Court held that res judicata generally cannot be decided under Order 7 Rule 11(d), because it needs the pleadings, issues and decision of the earlier suit. The plaint alone rarely shows it. Raise res judicata in the written statement.

Do not assume it will be tried first as a preliminary issue. Under Order XIV Rule 2(2), the court may try an issue first only if it is an issue of law relating to the court's jurisdiction or a bar created by law, and it can dispose of the suit. In Sathyanath v. Sarojamani, 2022 INSC 529, the Supreme Court set aside a direction to try res judicata as a preliminary issue, because deciding it needed the earlier pleadings and findings, which made it a mixed question of law and fact. Ask for a preliminary issue only where the bar can be decided on admitted facts and the record alone; otherwise it is decided with the other issues after evidence.

Statutory bars

Common bars raised under clause (d), each depending on the statute and the facts pleaded:

  • No notice under Section 80 CPC in a suit against the Government or a public officer, where no leave was obtained under Section 80(2).
  • An express or implied bar under Section 9 CPC, where a special statute gives exclusive jurisdiction to a tribunal or authority (for example, matters a Debts Recovery Tribunal must decide under the SARFAESI Act).
  • Section 41 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, which lists cases where an injunction cannot be granted.
  • No pre-institution mediation in a commercial suit (below).

Commercial suits and Section 12A

Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 requires pre-institution mediation before a commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief. In Patil Automation Pvt. Ltd. v. Rakheja Engineers Pvt. Ltd., decided on 17 August 2022, the Supreme Court held the requirement mandatory: a suit filed in breach must be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11. The Court made this prospective from 20 August 2022. Later decisions have held that merely filing an interim application does not excuse mediation; the court checks whether urgent interim relief was genuinely contemplated.

The plaint is rejected as a whole, or not at all

In Sejal Glass Ltd. v. Navilan Merchants Pvt. Ltd., (2018) 11 SCC 780, the Supreme Court held that Order 7 Rule 11 applies to the plaint as a whole. A court cannot reject it against some defendants or for some reliefs and let the rest continue. Madhav Prasad Aggarwal v. Axis Bank Ltd., (2019) 7 SCC 158, followed this.

So if one relief is time-barred but another is within time, or the plaint survives against one defendant, an Order 7 Rule 11 application will fail. Use other tools instead: strike out pleadings under Order VI Rule 16, ask for deletion of a party under Order I Rule 10(2), or, where the bar is a pure question of law on jurisdiction or a statutory bar, ask for it to be tried as a preliminary issue under Order XIV Rule 2(2).

Order 7 Rule 11 application format

This format is for a defendant in a civil suit before a trial court. Adapt the cause title, clause and grounds to your case and your court's practice. File it early, ideally before the written statement, but do not treat it as pausing your written statement deadline (see the next section).

IN THE COURT OF THE [CIVIL JUDGE (SENIOR DIVISION) / ____], [PLACE]

Civil Suit No. ____ of 20__

[Name of Plaintiff]                                    ... Plaintiff
                              Versus
[Name of Defendant(s)]                                 ... Defendant(s)

APPLICATION UNDER ORDER VII RULE 11 [(a) / (d)] READ WITH SECTION 151
OF THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908 FOR REJECTION OF THE PLAINT

The Defendant [No. __] most respectfully submits as under:

1. The Plaintiff has filed the above suit seeking [relief: declaration /
   injunction / recovery of Rs. ____], on the averments in paragraphs
   [__] of the plaint.

2. This application is decided on the averments in the plaint and the
   documents filed with it, taken as true. The Defendant does not admit
   them, and reserves the right to contest them if the suit proceeds.

3. GROUND 1 - THE PLAINT DISCLOSES NO CAUSE OF ACTION [Order VII
   Rule 11(a)]
   (a) The relief claimed depends on [the Plaintiff's title / a contract /
       a right] which the plaint itself does not plead. [Quote or cite the
       paragraph.]
   (b) Even taken as true, paragraphs [__] do not give the Plaintiff a
       right to [relief], because [reason, with the provision].

4. GROUND 2 - THE SUIT IS BARRED BY LAW [Order VII Rule 11(d)]
   (a) [Limitation] The plaint states at paragraph [__] that [event] took
       place on [date], and the document at [page __] filed with the plaint
       is dated [date]. The period for this suit is [__] years under
       Article [__] of the Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963, which
       expired on [date]. The suit was filed on [date]. The plaint pleads no
       ground of exclusion or extension. Under Section 3 the suit must be
       dismissed.
   (b) [Or: statutory bar] The suit is barred by [Section __ of ____ Act]
       because [reason appearing from the plaint].

5. The plaint cannot be saved by clever drafting. Paragraph [__] pleads
   [a legal notice dated ____ / a refusal dated ____] as the cause of
   action, but the plaint itself shows the grievance arose on [date].

6. Under Saleem Bhai v. State of Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557 and
   Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali, (2020) 7 SCC 366, this
   application may be decided before the written statement is filed.

PRAYER

It is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
(a) reject the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 [(a) / (d)] CPC;
(b) award costs to the Defendant; and
(c) pass any other order this Hon'ble Court deems fit.

[Place]                                    [Defendant]
[Date]                                     Through Counsel

[Supporting affidavit, if your court's practice requires one]

Three things make this application work:

  • Paragraph numbers from the plaint. Every ground should cite the plaint's own paragraph or document page. A ground the court cannot find in the plaint will be rejected.
  • One clause per ground. Do not mix "no cause of action" with "barred by law" in a single paragraph. The tests differ.
  • No disputed facts. If a ground needs your version of events, it is a written statement point, not a Rule 11 point. A weak application also signals your defence early.

For the supporting affidavit, see the affidavit format guide.

The written statement deadline keeps running

The court may decide an Order 7 Rule 11 application before the written statement is filed, but filing the application does not stop the time for filing the written statement. Plan for the application to fail.

SuitTime for the written statement under Order VIII Rule 1Effect of a pending Rule 11 application
Ordinary civil suit30 days from service of summons, extendable by the court for reasons recorded, up to 90 days. In Kailash v. Nanhku, (2005) 4 SCC 480, the Supreme Court held the 90-day limit directory, so courts may allow later filing only in exceptional casesNot a ground of extension in itself. Ask the court for directions on time when you file the application, and do not let the period lapse waiting for the order
Commercial suit30 days, extendable up to 120 days from service of summons. After that the defendant forfeits the right to file it, and the court cannot take it on recordNo excuse. In SCG Contracts (India) Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., (2019) 12 SCC 210, the Supreme Court held that the pendency of an Order VII Rule 11 application is not a valid reason for missing the 120 days

In a commercial suit, file the written statement within 120 days of service even while the application is pending, and repeat the Rule 11 grounds in it as preliminary objections. In an ordinary suit, doing the same is the safe course.

Reply format for the plaintiff

If you act for the plaintiff, the reply should show that the grounds need a trial.

REPLY ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF TO THE APPLICATION UNDER ORDER VII
RULE 11 CPC FILED BY THE DEFENDANT [No. __]

1. The application relies on facts that are not in the plaint, namely
   [____]. These are matters of defence and are irrelevant under Order
   VII Rule 11 (Saleem Bhai v. State of Maharashtra, (2003) 1 SCC 557).

2. Read as a whole with its documents, the plaint discloses a cause of
   action at paragraphs [__]: [summarise the right, the breach and the
   relief].

3. [Limitation] The cause of action arose on [date] as pleaded at
   paragraph [__]. Whether it arose earlier is disputed and is a mixed
   question of law and fact that needs evidence (P. Kumarakurubaran v.
   P. Narayanan, 2025 INSC 598).

4. [If relevant] The plaint cannot be rejected in part. Even if [one
   relief / one defendant] were affected, the suit survives for
   [other relief / other defendants] (Sejal Glass Ltd. v. Navilan
   Merchants Pvt. Ltd., (2018) 11 SCC 780).

PRAYER
Dismiss the application with costs.

[Plaintiff], through Counsel

After the order: appeal or revision

OrderNatureRemedy
Plaint rejectedA decree under Section 2(2) CPCFirst appeal under Section 96 CPC. Limitation under Article 116 of the Limitation Act: 90 days to a High Court, 30 days to any other court
Application dismissedAn order, not a decree, and not listed in Order XLIIINo appeal. A revision under Section 115 CPC or a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution, depending on your High Court's practice
Plaint returned under Rule 10An appealable orderAppeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(a)

A rejected plaintiff can also file a fresh suit on the same cause of action under Order VII Rule 13, but it must be within limitation and must cure the defect. Under Rule 12, the judge must record the order rejecting the plaint with reasons.

If the appeal is late, see the condonation of delay guide. For other appealable orders, see the Order 43 guide.

Drafting a plaint that survives Order 7 Rule 11

Most rejections can be avoided at the drafting stage:

  1. Plead every fact the cause of action needs: the right, the breach, when and where it happened, and why the relief follows.
  2. Plead the limitation paragraph honestly. State the article of the Schedule, the starting date and any exclusion (Sections 12 to 15, acknowledgment under Section 18, a continuing wrong under Section 22).
  3. Value the suit and pay court fee correctly, with the valuation paragraph showing the basis. See the declaration suit court fee guide.
  4. Complete the pre-suit steps: a Section 80 notice in a suit against the Government, and pre-institution mediation or a pleaded urgent interim relief in a commercial suit.
  5. File the documents you rely on with the plaint, and file the duplicate and service copies.

For the defendant's next step if the application fails, see the written statement guide.

आदेश 7 नियम 11 सीपीसी: Hindi summary

आदेश 7 नियम 11 सिविल प्रक्रिया संहिता, 1908 के अंतर्गत न्यायालय बिना विचारण के वाद पत्र (plaint) को नामंजूर कर सकता है।

  • वाद पत्र में वाद कारण (cause of action) प्रकट न हो, या वाद पत्र के कथनों से ही वाद किसी विधि से वर्जित हो, तो वाद पत्र नामंजूर होगा।
  • मूल्यांकन या कोर्ट फीस में कमी होने पर पहले न्यायालय समय देगा; उसके बाद भी कमी रहने पर ही नामंजूरी होगी।
  • केवल वाद पत्र और उसके साथ दाखिल दस्तावेज़ देखे जाते हैं; प्रतिवादी का लिखित कथन इस चरण पर अप्रासंगिक है।
  • वाद पत्र नामंजूर होना डिक्री है, जिसके विरुद्ध धारा 96 सीपीसी में प्रथम अपील होती है।

Draft it from your case file

Juniorlawyer's template library includes an Order 7 Rule 11 format with its statutory basis. Upload the plaint, and you can draft the application or the reply in this structure, then check every paragraph reference, date and citation against the record before filing. See how to use templates in Juniorlawyer.

_This article is for general information and is not legal advice. Check the current text of the CPC, the judgments cited and the practice of your court before filing._

Choose your next step

What would you like to improve in your practice workflow?

What should I ask a vendor before uploading client documents?

  1. Ask about access, retention, deletion and service providers.
  2. Test with an anonymized sample and inspect the export.
  3. Compare current plan limits with your actual workload.
Use the software evaluation guide

Frequently Asked Questions

Share this article

Try JuniorLawyer on your next matter

Draft, translate, run OCR and research in one workspace. Free plan, no credit card required.

Draft your Order 7 Rule 11 application with Juniorlawyer

Prefer a walkthrough? Book a demo